ClearEaty

Healthiest nut butters

Ranked by ClearEaty's ingredient-quality score — highest first. These are our opinion of the cleanest nut butters we've scored, based on their real ingredient lists.

Check your own nut butters — get the app

17 nut butters shown, best score first.

  1. 9Raw Almond Butter CreamyExcellent
  2. 9Organic Creamy Almond ButterExcellent
  3. 9Creamy Almond ButterExcellent
  4. 9Peanut ButterExcellent
  5. 9Organic Creamy Peanut ButterExcellent
  6. 9Natural Almond ButterExcellent
  7. 8Natural Peanut ButterGood
  8. 8Organic peanut butter countGood
  9. 7PEANUT BUTTER SPREADGood
  10. 7Almond ButterGood
  11. 7Original Powdered Peanut ButterGood
  12. 6Almond Butter SmoothOK
  13. 5Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter SpreadOK
  14. 5Jif Peanut Butter SpreadOK
  15. 4Creamy Peanut ButterPoor
  16. 4Reese's 2 Peanut Butter CupsPoor
  17. 2REESE'S MINIATURE CUPSBad

Browse all scored foods →